Soft homemade sandwich bread for PB&Js, toast, and grilled cheese—with an optional smaller jalapeño cheddar loaf from the same dough.
part of the rooted pantry project
- makes
- two loaves: one large and one small Pullman
- how we use it
- plain sandwich bread, an optional savory loaf, and freezer PB&Js
quick note: this post may contain affiliate links. if you buy through them, i may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. i only share things i actually use or would recommend.
why we make this
we’re starting the rooted pantry project with sandwich bread because this is the swap that made me realize homemade was actually sticking.
not in a perfect homemaker way.
more in a “i almost grabbed the easy thing and my kid called me out” kind of way.
my daughter told me to make my delicious bread instead, so sandwich bread was the obvious place to start.
sandwich bread is one of those things that disappears constantly in our house.
pb&j, toast, grilled cheese, quick lunches, random hungry kid moments — it is one of the easiest store-bought staples to keep buying without thinking about it.
but this homemade version is soft, fluffy, flavorful, and freezes well. it is one of the swaps that actually makes sense for our family.
that does not mean i will never buy bread again. we live in the real world over here.
but if i have the time and the pans, this one is absolutely worth making.
honestly, the only thing i would change is owning more pullman pans so i could bake more at once and do it less often.
soft sandwich bread
a soft homemade sandwich bread made with milk, honey, whole wheat flour, and flax, with an optional small jalapeño cheddar loaf if you want one plain loaf and one savory loaf.
ingredients
for the sandwich bread dough
- 415 ml warm milk, plus more as needed
- 10 g active dry yeast
- 60 g honey
- 2 eggs
- 60 g butter, melted and slightly cooled
- 700 g bread flour
- 100 g whole wheat flour
- 15 g ground flaxseed
- 10 g salt
optional variation: jalapeño cheddar loaf
this is optional. the base sandwich bread is the main root.
- 75-100 g cheddar cubes
- 1 small jalapeño, thinly sliced and chopped
instructions
1. wake up the yeast
add the warm milk, honey, and active dry yeast to a large mixing bowl.
let it sit for 5–10 minutes, until the yeast looks foamy.
if it does absolutely nothing, your yeast may be dead or your milk may have been too hot. annoying, but better to find out now than after adding all the flour.
2. add the wet ingredients
add the eggs and melted butter to the yeast mixture.
stir until combined.
3. add the dry ingredients
add the bread flour, whole wheat flour, ground flaxseed, and salt.
mix until a shaggy dough forms.
4. knead the dough
knead the dough by hand until it becomes smooth, soft, and stretchy.
if using a stand mixer, attach the dough hook and knead on low for about 8–10 minutes, stopping to check the dough as needed.
if the dough feels dry, stiff, or tight, add a small splash of warm milk at a time until it softens. i almost always need a little extra milk here, and sometimes a little more than i expect.
the dough should feel soft and workable. not sticky soup, but not tough either.
5. let it rise
place the dough in a lightly greased bowl, cover it, and let it rise until doubled.
this usually takes about 1–2 hours, depending on how warm your kitchen is.
6. divide the dough
turn the dough out and divide it for your pans.
i use one larger portion for my 2.2 lb pullman loaf pan and one smaller portion for my 1 lb pullman loaf pan.
the bigger loaf usually stays plain because we need more bread for pb&j, toast, grilled cheese, and kid lunches.
the smaller loaf is where i like to make the jalapeño cheddar version. two of my kids do not eat spicy, so we need the bigger loaf for regular sandwich bread.
7. shape the plain sandwich loaf
gently press the larger portion of dough into a rectangle.
roll it up tightly, pinch the seam closed, and place it seam-side down in the large pullman pan.
8. shape the jalapeño cheddar loaf
gently press the smaller portion of dough into a rectangle.
scatter the cheddar cubes and chopped jalapeño over the dough, leaving a little space around the edges.
roll the dough up tightly, pinch the seam closed, and place it seam-side down in the small pullman pan.
9. let the loaves rise again
cover both pans and let the loaves rise until puffy and close to the top of the pans.
for pullman pans, you want the dough to rise nicely, but not aggressively overflow.
10. bake
bake at 350°f until the loaves are golden and baked through.
start checking around:
- 25–30 minutes for the smaller loaf
- 35–45 minutes for the larger loaf
the bread is done when the center reaches about 190–200°f.
let the loaves cool before slicing, even though waiting for warm bread to cool is rude and unfair.
tools that make this easier
you do not need every gadget to make bread, but these are the tools i reach for when i’m making this recipe on repeat.
storing and freezing
this bread freezes really well, but i usually do not slice the whole loaf before freezing.
if i’m freezing the large loaf, i like to cut it in half first so it is easier to thaw and use. once the bread is fully cooled, i wrap it and freeze it. if i vacuum seal it, i freeze it solid first so the vacuum does not crush the soft loaf.
if i’m making freezer pb&j, that is when i slice it first.
for freezer pb&j, i like to assemble the sandwiches, flash freeze them until firm, and then vacuum seal them so they do not get smashed into one sad frozen brick.
For those PB&Js, homemade doesn’t have to mean every ingredient. My peanut butter test ended in BUY.
FAQ
Can I use regular loaf pans?
Yes, but the shape and bake time may change. The recipe describes my Pullman pans; the existing bake guidance is to check the center at about 190–200°F.
Do I have to use whole wheat flour and flaxseed?
That is how I make this recipe. If you change the flour, you may need to adjust the milk because different flours absorb liquid differently.
Why does my dough feel tight?
It may need more milk. Follow the small-splash adjustment in the kneading step rather than adding it all at once.
Can I make both loaves plain?
Yes—skip the cheddar and jalapeño and shape both as plain sandwich loaves.
Can I make the whole batch jalapeño cheddar?
The original variation allows it, but I usually keep the larger loaf plain for the kids’ lunches. The listed add-ins are for the small loaf.
the rooted pantry verdict: MAKE
This is the bread my kids ask for, and it works for our everyday sandwiches as well as freezer PB&Js. If I have the time and the pans, it earns the effort. That doesn’t mean I’ll never buy bread again.
keep growing the rooted pantry
We’re figuring out what is worth making at home—and what can stay at the grocery store.